booking guide

Comedy Nights vs Quizzes, Concerts and Auctions: The Real Numbers on Turnout and Cost

A plain comparison of church fundraiser formats on cost, ticket price, turnout and paperwork, and how a comedy night stacks up on profit per head.

You have a roof fund, a mission partner or an Alpha launch to pay for, and someone at the PCC or leadership meeting has said the words "we could do a quiz". Fair enough. Quizzes work. But before you default to the format you ran last year, it is worth putting the options side by side on the two things that decide whether a fundraiser succeeds: how many people actually turn up, and how much of the money you keep.

The three numbers that decide everything

Every fundraiser format, from a cake sale to a black tie dinner, comes down to the same maths:

Multiply the last two, subtract the first, add whatever you make on the bar, raffle and refreshments. That is your evening. Most disappointing church fundraisers fail because the ticket price the format supports is low and the effort is high, not because nobody came.

Quiz night: cheapest to run, lowest ceiling

Quizzes are the reliable workhorse. Near zero fixed cost if a volunteer writes the questions, and typical UK charity pricing sits around £5 to £10 a head, or £30 to £50 a table. Break even is almost immediate, which is why they feel safe.

The catch is the ceiling. At £8 a head with 80 people, you are looking at roughly £640 before the raffle, and the same core group tends to come every time. Quizzes also reward the confident and mildly punish everyone else, which makes them a harder thing to invite a nervous neighbour to.

Concerts and recitals: lovely, but check the licence

A concert can charge more than a quiz and looks properly special. Two things to budget for. First, music licensing: the PRS for Music Church Licence obtained through CCLI covers a limited number of live performances outside worship each year, so check where you stand before you sell a ticket. Second, appeal. Choral or classical evenings draw a devoted but narrow crowd, and if your aim is outreach as well as income, the guest list tends to be people already inside the building.

Auctions of promises and gala dinners: highest ceiling, highest effort

These raise the most per head by a distance, because you are selling to people who arrive intending to spend. They also demand months of volunteer work chasing lots, sorting catering and selling tables, and they only work if you have a pool of supporters with money to give. Brilliant for a capital appeal. Punishing if you run one every year with the same six volunteers.

Comedy night: one fixed fee, a much better ticket price

A comedy night sits in the middle in the most useful way. It carries a real fixed cost, the act's fee, but it supports a ticket price closer to £12 to £20 rather than £5 to £8, because people are used to paying real money to be made to laugh. That gap is the whole argument. Sell 120 tickets at £15 instead of 120 at £8 and the extra £840 covers a professional booking with room to spare.

The turnout difference matters more than the money. A comedy night is the easiest church event in the calendar to invite someone to, because nobody has to sing, guess a capital city or bid on a hamper. They just have to sit down. That is why they work so well as an Alpha launch or a first-visit event, and it means your congregation does your marketing for you.

The admin nobody mentions in the meeting

How to de-risk the fixed fee

The only real objection to a comedy night is the deposit-shaped worry: what if we do not sell enough. Do the sum before you commit. Divide the total fixed cost by your ticket price to get your break even head count, then ask honestly whether 40 households in your church can each bring two people. If yes, you are covered before you print a poster.

Then protect the number. Sell tickets in person after services for three consecutive weeks rather than relying on a link, and set a modest table or group rate so people commit in fours instead of ones. Booking an act with television or festival credits helps here too. It gives your congregation something concrete to say when they invite someone, and "you'll have heard of them" sells more tickets than "it should be a good night".

None of this makes quizzes wrong. It makes them one tool. If your aim this year is a bigger room with more new faces in it, the format that charges more and asks less of the audience is usually the one to back.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much should we charge for tickets to a church comedy night?
A comedy night comfortably supports a ticket price of around £12 to £20 a head, compared with the £5 to £10 most charity quiz nights can ask. People are already used to paying real money to be made to laugh, so the higher price rarely dents turnout. That price gap is what pays for a professional act and still leaves a healthy margin for your fund.

Is a comedy night more profitable than a quiz night for a church fundraiser?
Usually yes, because of the ticket price rather than the crowd size. A quiz has almost no fixed cost but a low ceiling: 80 people at £8 brings in roughly £640 before the raffle. Sell 120 comedy tickets at £15 instead of £8 and the extra £840 covers a professional booking with room to spare, plus you tend to get more new faces in the room.

How do we work out our break even for booking a comedian?
Divide the total fixed cost, mainly the act's fee plus any venue or PA hire, by your ticket price. That gives you the number of tickets you must sell before you make a penny. Then ask honestly whether around 40 households in your church can each bring two people, and if the answer is yes you are covered before you print a poster.

Can we claim Gift Aid on fundraiser ticket sales?
No, Gift Aid cannot be claimed on ticket income because a ticket buys the purchaser a benefit, namely admission to the event. You can claim on separate, genuine donations given on the night, so it is worth building a clearly labelled giving moment into the running order. Keep that giving distinct from the ticket price in all your paperwork and publicity.

What admin do we need to sort out for a church fundraising event with a bar and raffle?
If you plan to sell alcohol you will normally need a Temporary Event Notice from your local council, which carries a modest fee, so check the gov.uk guidance before promising a bar. A raffle sold only on the night at the event is treated differently from one where tickets go on sale in advance, and the latter may need registering with your local authority as a small society lottery. If you are running a concert rather than a comedy night, also check your PRS for Music Church Licence position through CCLI, as it covers only a limited number of live performances outside worship each year.

Ready to see it for yourself?

Watch a showreel, meet the comics, and find a tour date near you.

Meet the Comics